Buttercream Flavours

This buttercream-y whipped topping gets sandwiched between each layer of your cake. It’s a versatile frosting that’s light, fluffy, and comes in almost any colour or flavour—making for one delicious dilemma.

The page identifies Grimsby, Ontario.

  • Vanilla

  • Chocolate Hazelnut

  • Chocolate Chip

  • Salted Caramel

  • Sprinkle

  • Cookies & Cream

  • Chocolate

  • Cookie Dough

  • Chocolate Peanut Butter

  • Lemon

Choosing a flavour

Start with the cake itself: do you want the buttercream to echo its flavour or give each bite a little contrast? Chocolate on chocolate makes for a rich bite, while vanilla lets a more strongly flavoured cake take the lead. Lemon can bring a bright note to a vanilla cake, and salted caramel pairs nicely with chocolate when you want a sweet-salty finish. If you're choosing for a crowd, think about texture as well as taste. Cookie pieces or chocolate chips can add a bit of crunch, while a smooth filling keeps the focus on the cake crumb. If you're torn between two flavours, picture the whole slice rather than tasting the frosting in your head on its own.

Questions

Does the filling have to match the frosting on the outside?

Not necessarily. A smooth outer frosting and a filling with mix-ins can give you a clean finish on the outside and a little crunch inside. Ask about the combination when discussing the cake design.

Does the buttercream flavour affect the cake price?

It can. Mix-ins and specialty ingredients may affect the quote, though serving count and the amount of decorating work usually matter more. Have your approximate guest count and design in mind when asking for a price.

What if a guest has a peanut or tree nut allergy?

Mention the allergy before choosing a flavour. Picking one without nuts in its name doesn't rule out cross-contact. Ask about ingredients and shared equipment before deciding what to serve.

Should buttercream cake be served straight from the fridge?

Buttercream is usually firmer when cold and softer as it warms. Follow the baker's storage and serving instructions, since the other fillings and the temperature of the room matter too.